Martyrdom
According to the life, the captured brothers were cast into prison and urged by their captor to abandon Christ for Islam, with false promises and, in some accounts, the efforts of sorcerers to break their resolve. They held firm. The OCA life preserves David's reply to the demand that he convert: that Muhammad had turned the Arabs from the worship of fire but could not give them the knowledge of the True God.
By tradition the brothers were led to a riverbank near a church of Saints Cosmas and Damian, beaten and bound, and drowned with heavy rocks hung from their necks. Their bodies were recovered by Christians and buried. One Georgian source dates the martyrdom to about the year 740.