Conflict in Minneapolis
Eastern-rite Catholic clergy in late nineteenth-century America occupied an uncertain place: their married priesthood and distinct liturgical tradition were viewed with suspicion by the Latin hierarchy. When Toth, a widowed Greek Catholic priest, made the customary call upon the local Latin bishop, Archbishop John Ireland, he was met with anger rather than welcome. By Toth's own account Ireland threw his priestly credentials onto the table and protested his presence in the city, declaring that he did not consider Toth or his bishop to be genuinely Catholic and refusing him faculties to serve in Minneapolis.
Sources differ on the precise sequence and dating of the return that followed. According to one account the parish, finding itself without recognized standing, contacted the Russian consul in San Francisco in December 1890 to be put in touch with a Russian Orthodox bishop, and Toth formally entered the Russian Orthodox Church in March 1892 together with 361 of his people. Other accounts place his reception by Bishop Vladimir (Sokolovsky) in February 1891, with the parish formally accepted in March 1892. In either telling, St. Mary's of Minneapolis became the first of the immigrant Uniate parishes to return to Orthodoxy under his leadership.