Arrest and the Surrender of the Books
The synaxarion presents the demand for the Scriptures as the heart of Timothy's confession. As a reader and copyist he had charge of the church's sacred books, and Governor Arian ordered him to deliver them up. Timothy refused, comparing the books to children whom a father could not betray to death, and his refusal to surrender the Scriptures, rather than a bare refusal to sacrifice to the idols, is what brings on his torments.
By tradition Timothy was first tortured by having red-hot iron rods or spits thrust through his ears, an injury the account associates with the loss of his sight. He was further hung head-downward, with wood placed in his mouth and a heavy stone bound to his neck.